Durham Ladies 1st XV 0 – 10 Cardiff Ladies 1st XV
A premature ending to a spirited second half performance put paid to Durham’s hopes of advancing to the second round of the BUCS Knock-out Cup.
Both teams decided to shake hands after Cardiff’s full back, Lela Hughes suffered a broken ankle in the 57th minute.
Players were visibly shocked after Hughes failed to get up from an inauspicious tackle with her ankle hanging at an awkward angle. One eye witness 15 metres away described the noise as “harrowing.”
The injury will have made the long return trip south a sombre one for Cardiff.
“It’s very demoralizing to see our friend and team mate like this. We can’t celebrate this win,” said Cardiff skipper, Jen Hawkins.
With the ambulance some time away and the score at 10-0 to Southern Premiership side Cardiff, Durham coach, Cameron Henderson offered Cardiff a route into the second round with 13 minutes remaining where they will face Loughborough.
But Durham skipper, Carolyn WIlson, was able to remain positive.
“I thought we adjusted well to the initial shock of coming up against opposition a league above us,” she told The Palatinate. “We could have scored in the second half. Nonetheless, it leaves us with the opportunity to concentrate on our main priority, winning the league.”
Despite entering the tie unbeaten and on the back of a 120-0 demolition of Manchester Met, Durham knew they were the underdogs and spent much of the first half trying to settle.
Cardiff’s superior physicality at the breakdown resulted in regular turnovers, faltering the momentum put in place by some fluid moves by the Durham backs, centring on fly half, Kate Langham.
And it was these turnovers that allowed Cardiff to capitalise on Durham’s temporarily ragged defensive line.
The speed at which Cardiff were able to counter attack and offload in the tackle was impressive, epitomised by their opening try.
The speed at which Cardiff were able to counter attack and offload in the tackle was impressive, epitomised by their opening try.
Cardiff’s powerful flanker, Claire Molloy was able to break a tackle across the half way line and suck in two more defenders before offloading to the grateful winger. Her speed was enough to evade the scrambling defence and score in the corner on 13 minutes.
If Cardiff’s first try was due to a moment of individual brilliance, there can be no excuses for the second.
A ruck inside Durham’s 22 resulted in an all too familiar turnover for Cardiff, who built up two more solid phases of play. With Durham’s defence at full stretch, Cardiff captain Jen Hawkins picked the ball off the back of the ruck and ignored the three women overlap to bundle across the line herself and double their lead.
As Durham struggled to impose them selves on the opposition’s try line, Cardiff could have made the game safe by half time but for a brilliant last ditch tackle by Durham’s number 10, Langham.
A moment of magic by Meg Tudor saw her collect her own chip on the half way line and break through the last line of defence. She looked a certainty to score if it wasn’t for Langham’s fantastic desire to pull her down just inches short of the line.
If Durham’s first half was characterised by glimpses of promising play by the backs that could not be sustained by the forwards, the opposite could be said of the second. The forwards were able to create a firm platform, but a series of handling errors meant the backs were unable to capitalise.
Durham’s imaginative moves were being increasingly well read by Cardiff’s centres, who delivered some big hits on Durham’s offensive line. This meant that Durham were not able to exploit full back Ruth Matta’s blistering pace and Cardiff’s pressure resulted in sloppy errors.
On the other hand, Matta executed her required defensive duties admirably. When Cardiff’s considerably sized centre, Sally Tuson performed one of her numerous line breaks and found herself with only the petite Matta standing between her and the try line the crowd feared the worst.
However, Matta brought down Tuson with ferocity that few could have predicted. “Have you ever seen a cheetah taking down a wilder beast on the Serengeti…?” one bystander turned to ask me.
With Durham’s forwards beginning to exert authority on the match, the premature end came as a disappointment. Whether they would have been able to stage a dramatic comeback will remain unseen, but their second half revival will be reassuring as they continue to aim for promotion.